Bench vs. QuickBooks: DIY or Outsource Your Bookkeeping?

You know you need bookkeeping—but the real question is how you should handle it?

Should you manage it yourself with QuickBooks, keeping everything in your hands but taking on the responsibility? Or should you outsource to a service like Bench, which will ensure expert bookkeeping and convenience but at a higher cost?

Each option has its advantages and limitations. QuickBooks provides customization and scalability, but it requires time, effort, and financial knowledge to use effectively.

Bench, on the other hand, offers fully managed bookkeeping, removing the workload but with less flexibility and limited reporting options.

And beyond these two, there are other alternatives that may better align with your business needs.

So, which solution makes the most sense for your business? In this blog, we’ll compare Bench vs. QuickBooks, explore additional alternatives, and help you decide whether to DIY your bookkeeping or outsource it to professionals.

What is Bench?

Bench Accounting is an online bookkeeping service designed for small businesses. Bench provides a team of professional bookkeepers who manage financial records on behalf of business owners.

The service works by connecting directly to business bank and credit card accounts, automatically importing transactions. Bench’s bookkeeping team then categorizes expenses, reconciles accounts, and prepares financial statements. Business owners can access their financial reports through a user-friendly dashboard, where they can review transactions, track cash flow, and generate reports.

While Bench streamlines bookkeeping and eliminates manual data entry, it is focused solely on bookkeeping and does not offer features like invoicing, bill pay, or tax filing by default. However, the company does provide a separate tax filing service for those who need additional support.

Bench is primarily suited for small businesses with straightforward bookkeeping needs, such as freelancers, e-commerce sellers, and service-based businesses that don’t require advanced accounting functions.

Here’s what Bench offers:

• Monthly bookkeeping – Each month, Bench bookkeepers categorize transactions, reconcile accounts, and generate financial statements, ensuring that records remain updated and accurate.
• Catch-up bookkeeping – Businesses that have fallen behind on their bookkeeping can use Bench’s catch-up service to organize past transactions and bring their books up to date.
• Income tax filing and advisory – Bench offers tax preparation and filing services for small businesses, along with year-round tax advisory, to help clients navigate tax obligations.
• Tax resolution support – The service includes assistance with IRS-related issues, such as back taxes, penalties, tax liens, and levies, helping businesses resolve outstanding tax liabilities.

What is QuickBooks?

That’s a huge majority, and it speaks to one thing — QuickBooks isn’t just popular; it’s the industry standard for small business accounting.

QuickBooks has been around for over 40 years, evolving from a simple desktop program into a powerful cloud-based platform that automates bookkeeping, streamlines tax prep, and integrates seamlessly with banks, payroll providers, and over 750 business apps. 

Here are some standout features of QuickBooks:

• Expense tracking – Automatically syncs with your bank and credit card accounts to log every transaction, so you always know where your money is going.
• Invoicing lets you create custom invoices, send them to clients, and even set automated payment reminders to avoid late payments.
• Payroll and tax management – With add-ons, QuickBooks helps you handle employee payroll, calculate deductions, and stay compliant with tax requirements.
• Financial reporting – Generates detailed reports like profit and loss statements, cash flow overviews, and inventory summaries to help you make data-driven decisions.
• Integrations – Works with over 750 apps, including Shopify, Stripe, and PayPal, making it easy to manage your financial ecosystem in one place.

Bench vs. QuickBooks: key differences

While both Bench and QuickBooks aim to simplify bookkeeping, they approach the task in fundamentally different ways. Choosing the right fit for your business starts with understanding how they compare.

Other DIY accounting software options

QuickBooks is a widely used accounting tool, but it may not be the right fit for every business.

• Complexity for small businesses – For business owners with less financial literacy, QuickBooks can feel overly complex, requiring a steep learning curve that may not justify the effort.
• Cost considerations – While QuickBooks offers various pricing plans, costs can escalate quickly if additional features like payroll, advanced reporting, or multi-user access are needed.
• Too many features for some businesses – Businesses that only need simple invoicing and expense tracking may find QuickBooks unnecessarily complicated, making alternatives like Wave or FreshBooks a better fit.
• Limited customer support on lower plans – Response times and support quality can be inconsistent, particularly on basic-tier plans, where users often experience delays in getting assistance.
• Lack of industry-specific features – Businesses in sectors like construction, e-commerce, and nonprofits may find that QuickBooks doesn’t fully meet their needs, making specialized tools like Sage or A2X more suitable.
• Cloud-based vs. desktop limitations – While QuickBooks Online offers flexibility, some businesses find that its reporting and inventory management tools don’t match the depth of QuickBooks Desktop. Conversely, QuickBooks Desktop users may find the lack of cloud access limiting.

If you have faced any of these challenges, it might be worth considering alternative bookkeeping solutions that better align with your needs.

Here’s a look at some alternatives:

Also read: 7 best accounting software in 2025 for self-employed individuals

Other bookkeeping service providers

Bench recently shut down and resumed operations after being acquired by Employer.com, creating uncertainty and shaking the trust of many customers. For business owners who want stable, reliable bookkeeping, it’s understandable to be cautious about Bench’s future.

Also read: Bench shutdown FAQs: All you need to know as a small business owner

Here are some top alternatives:

Also read: Top 5 Bench Accounting alternatives for small business owners

DIY vs. outsourcing: how to decide

As a business owner, your time should be spent on growing your business, managing clients, and overseeing projects—not on bookkeeping. Yet, many business owners attempt to manage their own books without the expertise or time to do it correctly.

Bookkeeping requires financial knowledge for accuracy and compliance with tax regulations. DIY bookkeeping often leads to misclassified expenses, cash flow mismanagement, missed deductions, and costly errors that can hurt your bottom line. 

While software like QuickBooks and Xero can automate some tasks, they don’t replace the need for financial expertise—you still need to interpret reports, reconcile accounts, and ensure compliance. Therefore, a DIY bookkeeping approach is not recommended at all.

Hiring an in-house bookkeeper provides dedicated oversight but comes with added payroll costs. Therefore, for many small businesses, outsourcing is the smarter, more cost-effective choice—giving you access to expert financial management without the expense of hiring full-time staff. A professional bookkeeper ensures your records are accurate, tax-ready, and optimized for profitability.

Also read: How to outsource bookkeeping for your small business

The bottom line

By the end of this blog, one thing is certain: handling your own bookkeeping is not the smartest move. Even if you feel confident managing it yourself, lack of financial expertise and limited time can lead to costly mistakes. While software can streamline the process, it’s not a replacement for professional knowledge and expert oversight.

If you’re looking for a bookkeeping solution that’s both efficient and cost-effective, CoCountant delivers the best of both worlds.

Our expert bookkeeping services combine expert financial management with modern tools, ensuring accuracy, compliance, and efficiency. Whether you need help catching up on bookkeeping backlog, maintaining tax compliance, or preparing monthly financial reports, we take care of your books—so you can focus on growing your business.

Start at just $160

FAQs